Hub911 - Emergency Services Information for all First Responders; Fire, EMS, LEO
LIKE us ->
  • Home
    • Free Medical Information Card
    • Contact Us
  • EMS
    • EMS Dept. Links
    • EMS Sponsors
    • EMS Classified Ads
    • EMS Events
    • EMS Forum
  • Fire & Rescue
    • Fire & Rescue Dept. Links
    • Fire & Rescue Sponsors
    • Fire & Rescue Classified Ads
    • Fire & Rescue Events
    • Fire & Rescue Forum
    • SOS Supply
  • Law Enforcement
    • Law Enforcement Dept. Links
    • Law Enforcement Sponsors
    • Law Enforcement Classified Ads
    • Law Enforcement Events
    • Law Enforcement Forums
  • Towing & Utilities
    • Tow Equip
    • Towing Company Links
    • Towing Company Sponsors
    • Towing Classified Ads
    • Towing Events
    • Towing & Utilities Forums
  • More
    • Dispatch
    • Explosives
    • HazMat
    • Lifeboat
    • Search & Rescue
    • U.S. Military >
      • Army
      • Navy
      • Air Force
      • Marines
      • Coast Guard
      • National Guard
      • Air National Guard
  • Forums
    • EMS Forums
    • Fire & Rescue Forums
    • Law Enforcement Forums
    • Towing & Utilities Forums
  • Info
    • Contact Us
    • Advertising >
      • Rate Page
      • Classified Ads
      • Links
      • Sponsorship
    • Resources
    • Disclaimer
    • State Listings
    • Site Map
  • Design
    • Website Design
    • SEO
    • Social Media Marketing
    • Hosting
    • Branding
    • Graphic Design
    • Printing
    • Signs and Banners
  • Blogs
    • Health Blog >
      • Mold Test Sale
    • Hub911 Blog
    • EMS Blog on Hub911
    • Fire Blog on Hub911
    • LEO Blog on Hub911
    • Towing Blog on Hub911 >
      • Positive Spin on Covid-19
      • COVID-19 and Isolationalism
    • PSA Blog
    • Hub911 Products Blog
    • Contests
    • Hub911 Recipies
  • Store
    • Service Animal Memorials
    • Contests
  • Print ID card
  • Parts Department Managment
  • New Page
  • New Page

Municipalities Use 'Cost Recovery Fees' to Pay for First Response

6/16/2012

2 Comments

 
Picture
Municipalities use 'cost recovery fees' to pay for first response
By JULIANNE MATTERA
| Times Herald

Wreck your car, suffer a house fire — be misfortune’s favorite in most St. Clair County communities and your expenses don’t end with paying an insurance deductible.Of 32 municipalities contacted by the Times Herald, 26 have some form of what’s called a cost-recovery fee allowing them to charge to recoup costs for fire departments responding to fires, emergency responses and traffic crashes.

Some even charge for police response in certain instances.

Mark Bell, 26, of Marine City said people pay taxes for fire and police protection.

“I feel that it’s not right by any means especially if you pay your taxes,” he said.

Bill Worthen, 61, of Algonac agreed.

“It’s like a double taxation,” Worthen said.

But he said he understood where municipalities were coming from.

“Everybody’s scraping for money,” Worthen said. “They’re trying to get whatever they can.”

That’s the rationale behind most cost-recovery ordinances. Berlin Township Supervisor Bill Winn, for example, said the township had never considered such an ordinance — until a fatal single-vehicle crash in April 2011 sucked a “good sum of money” from the township’s funds.

He said 13 Berlin Township firefighters spent seven hours looking for a man missing from the crash scene on Belle River Road near Berville Road. The man they were looking for, a 22-year-old man from Allenton, had fled the scene.

Winn tried to recoup some of the costs, but learned the township needed a cost-recovery ordinance.

“Our fire department said it’s the worst accident they’ve ever seen,” Winn said. “That’s the reason we have a cost-recovery ordinance now.”

The township passed the ordinance in November. It specifically covers fees for crashes that are drug- or alcohol-related, Winn said.

Some municipalities use cost-recovery ordinances to fund fire departments. Others use it aso residents don’t wind up paying for fires and accidents vcaused by non-residents.

Still others enacted a cost-recovery ordinance to increase revenue needed to keep up with the rising cost of providing services.

Joe Thesing, assistant vice president for state affairs at the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, said municipalities in at least 27 states have considered or adopted accident response fee ordinances for police and/or fire response. There have been talks about the fees in 34 states.A total of 13 states have passed legislation prohibiting the collection of accident response fees. States where the practice is banned are Missouri, Pennsylvania, Indiana, Georgia, Tennessee, Arkansas, Florida, Oklahoma, Louisiana, Alabama, Utah, Arizona and Kansas.

Thesing said people in general don’t like accident response fees. Citing a Harris Interactive Poll, Thesing said the majority of Americans think their taxes should pay for the cost of public safety services provided by police and fire departments responding to vehicle crashes. The poll found 76% of adults believe additional accident response fees charged by local governments are not necessary.

“They believe the taxes they’re paying should cover these services,” Thesing said.

Michael LaFaive, director of fiscal policy for the Mackinac Center for Public Policy in Midland, said the cost response fees could be good or bad depending on how they’re used by the municipality. He said the extra fees could be a “tax by another name” if police and fire serivces in municipalities are paid through by taxes already.

But he said the extra fees could be good if they thwart over-consumption of services.

Clay Township Clerk Lisa White said her township adopted a cost-recovery ordinance in July of 2010. The ordinance specifically deals with nonresidents, and mainly was because of the amount of resources the township dedicates to the annual Jobbie Nooner party on Lake St. Clair.

“We’re not trying to nickel and dime our citizens,” White said. “... It was really costing the taxpayers quite a bit to just do this one event that wasn’t even sanctioned.”

In Marine City, people charged with accident response fees must be involved in a vehicle crash or have an incident at their home more than once in the same calendar year, Assistant Fire Chief Richard Tucker said.

A China Township man who crashed into a telephone pole on Parker Street was not charged for the incident Wednesday. Tucker said that was because it was the man’s first vehicle crash in the city this year.

Contact Julianne Mattera  Follow her on Twitter @jumattera.

--
Sherry Wood 104wood@gmail.com 810.479.2223 www.hub911.com    or @sherrywood

2 Comments

Memories of a Fire Chief: Wood Spokes & Ladders by Frank D. Harrisson

3/30/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
It amuses me to no end to hear about the problems of the fire service today that we who have survived from those same problems that occurred in the last century. In those days we learned to read a fire's advance or action by using our ears, eyes, nose, and feel. With all of the gear they wear today they do not know when they are in trouble until it is to late. We knew when it got untenable or unstable and we got out. We had backdraughts and smoke explosions in those days as well but we learned to recognize them although I did get caught one time and got blown off of the porch roof into a hedgerow that saved me. It was a lack of communication, no radios in those days.

It was a cold winter's night and a strong wind was blowing from the North. It was a converted three story twin dwelling that was now comprised of six apartments. Apparently the man who rented the third floor Painted his apartment and went away for the weekend. Oily rags, brushes and paints were stored in the closet. That is a no, no and sure enough spontaneous combustion took out the attic and third floor before we got there. As a standard procedure in our fire district a house firecalls for a second alarm. The second in company takes the backside of the facility on fire. As you would have it, the house faced South. The rear of the dwelling had a fire escape built on as required by law. The fire was encroaching the second floor front from above. I had ,laddered upto the porch roof with a Pompier Axe. there was a hose team with a charged 1 1/2 inch behind me but still on the ladder. The way that the windows were blackened and bulging, very hot with a red glow and smoke through every crack and seam of the clap board siding I knew that we were going to catch hell as soon as I opened that window. What I did not expect was the fact the second in company opened up the third floor before we were ready and that North Wind blowing in on the third floor, oh my! when I applied that Pompier Axe to open that second floor bedroom window, I caught window frame, flames, and blast and got blown off the roof over top of the hose crew. There I was laying in the hedges and Doctor Fox and others trying to pull me out. I was not injured but I was one shaken individual. Doctor Fox had me sit on the running board of the ladder truck drinking coffee and smoking my pipe until I stopped shaking.






Frank D. Harrisson
Fire Chief (Ret.)

0 Comments

    Hub911.com

    Enjoy! Feel free to email ideas for topics or if you want to be a guest blogger.

    Archives

    April 2016
    December 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    November 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012

    Categories

    All
    \
    1966
    1975
    3 Wishes
    911
    Alert
    Alexander Griffin
    Ambulance
    Army
    Backdraft
    Believe In Santa
    Blog
    Blown Off Roof
    Book
    Brother
    Brothers
    Bryan Fass
    Carpe Diem
    Charlie Brown
    Checklist
    Chevrolet
    Christmas Eve For Linemen
    Cmas
    Congress
    Cost Recovery Fees
    Cyanide Exposure
    Dan Heidt
    Declarations
    Delivery
    Dial 9 Then 911
    Dialing 911 In Hotel Or Office
    Disabled American Veterans
    Dispatch
    Dispatcher
    Disposable Heroes
    Dodge
    Domino’s Pizza
    Edmund Fitzgerald
    Edmund Gratz
    Emergency
    Emergency Personnel
    Emergency Servicees Information
    Emergency Services
    Emergency Services Information
    Emergency Services Personnel
    Ems
    Emt
    Family
    Father
    Fire
    Fire Chief
    Fire Department
    Fire Departments
    Fire Dept
    Firefighter
    Fire Fitness
    Fire Safety Messages
    First Response
    Fitness Guide For Public Safety Professionals
    Fit Responder
    Ford
    Frank D. Harrisson
    Franz Stigler
    Friends
    Generator
    Gm
    Goals
    Hank Hunt
    Harlem
    Hazard
    History
    Hub911
    Hub911.com
    Hub911.com
    Hydrogen Cyanide Awareness
    Iraq
    July 3
    Kevin Hughes
    Key
    Kids
    Kurt Kamm
    La
    Ladders
    Ladder Truck
    Law Enforcement
    Legislation
    Leo
    Leprechaun
    Lfg Command Systems
    Lifestyle
    Lineman
    Linemen
    Los Angeles
    Malasian Jet
    Manager
    Michael Meakin
    Michigan
    Mismatched Photos
    Missing Jet
    Name
    New York
    Nick Kemper
    No Back Up
    Nov 10
    Ocean Bomber
    Organization
    Paramedic
    Parts Guy
    Patrol Cars
    Phoenix
    Police
    Police Officer
    Pompier Axe
    Pride In A Nation
    Proof Of Santa
    Public Safety
    Public Service
    Ring
    Safe
    Safe Haven For Newborns
    Safety
    Santa Claus Does Exist
    Saved Life
    September 9
    Sherry Wood
    Song
    Star Spangled Banner
    Texas
    The National Fire Protection Association
    Todd Platner
    Tom Giorgi
    Towing
    Towing Industry: Driver
    Tow Truck
    Traffic Crashes
    Unicorn
    United States
    Urban Legends
    Vehicle
    Vehicles
    Via Motors
    Vietnam
    Volunteer
    Wea
    Wood Spokes
    Wrecker
    Wwii
    Www.hub911.com

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.